Texto de David Coscina, escrito en jwfan en 2008. Los que no tengáis problemas con el inglés leedlo con calma, me sirve para sintetizar todo lo que pienso sobre este asunto:
So, since some of us get heat for spouting off our vitriole regarding everyone's reviled film composer, let's try to ascertain why we keep doing so. Even though the topic title implies or rather expects to garner the usual one-liners, I would like to thoughtfully probe WHY Zimmer is reviled so much, especially on this forum.
1. He hails from pop music background.
Okay, so is this really a crime? Danny Elfman also comes from Oingo Boingo and receives a lot less heat. WRONG. When Elfman first tackled Batman (1989) he was berated by the establishment and outright called a "guy who lazily gets orchestrators and conductors to write his music" by a professor of composition (Micah B. Rubenstein) in KEYBOARD magazine back in 1989 (to which Elfman wrote a thoughtful rebuttal save for the sentence where he calls Rubenstein a "dumb f*&^"). But Elfman's influences were Herrmann, Prokofiev, Shostakovich, Kurt Weill among others that obviously allowed him to draw from a richer harmonic and orchestral tapestry when he was doing such memorable scores like Edward Scissorhands, Dick Tracy, and The Nightmare Before Christmas. Also, Elfman HAS evolved throughout the years and has stretched beyond his more tonal bonds of his early film career. Aside from Steve Bartek and a conductor, he's done the composing himself. No 5 other composers listed on separate cues. While he also likes to use electronics, he retains an organic, acoustic sound to his music. He rarely doubles a French Horn with a CS80 or some such nonsense. Where Zimmer developed his trademark sound through outside sources (like patches on synthesizers or doubling things with synths), Elfman's sound has been signified by chordal or harmonic turn of phrases. He's also a much better contrapuntalist than Zimmer will ever hope to be. And because John Williams is so strong with this, it goes to the point that ardent Williams fans would not necessarily like the disparity in qualitative approach to making music.
This is really a loaded section because pop music also denotes simpler music structures. This is why I theorize ZImmer is so popular. His music is emotionally immediate. It's very palpable and digestible. There are never any big chunks to chew on and mull about. It's also very viscerally overwhelming which is also why I suspect people get so irate and defensive because a criticism of Zimmer is a criticism of their own feelings. Fair enough. I can accept this.
2. Zimmer employs various people to help complete a score
So, Hans Zimmer once upon a time was given a chance to enter the world of film scoring by Stanley Myers (the guy who is largely known for that lovely Cavatina from The Deer Hunter). In the spirit of "paying it forward" he create a place where he could bring untapped talent to the forefront. One of his first finds was Mark Mancina who we all know scored SPEED and then went on to a fairly decent career. He still is writing although seems to have distanced himself from MV. Anyhow, Mancina's resume was surprisingly stacked with rock credits having done some work with Keith Emerson among others from the prog rock generation. Hardly a novice by the time he got to Hollywood.
Mancina also aided Zimmer in his Oscar winning Lion King score BTW. Later additions to Media Ventures were John Powell (whom I like and respect a fair bit), Harry Gregson-Williams, Jeff Rona (who had been writing excellent film scoring articles for years for KEYBOARD), Klaus Badelt, to more recent guys like Steve Jablonsky. If you read any one of their CVs, you will see a crapload of credits and experience in the music industry before they ever set foot in the hallowed hallways of Remote Control Productions. So, what Zimmer was in truth looking for were guys who had resumes that reflected they were proven commodities but not well enough known to garner attention to the fact that they would be assisting him (writing actual cues) for his projects. Once Zimmer's altruism turned to assembly line, it was a downturn in the film music industry were scores from any one of his underlings sounded exactly the same. Thus the homogenous, predictable age of scoring came prevalent in Hollywood. Another reason to dislike him.
3. Hans Zimmer HAS range
Er, no, his co-writers do. When you employ so many underlings, it's of course possible to have a sound the varies from score to score. But sadly, I personally can hear the same diminished to I chord cadence for every dramatic revelation in every one of his damned scores. What is really upsetting is that once in a while, Zimmer does come up with a interesting idea, like that ascending glide for The Dark Knight, because of the inclusion of so many hands in the pot, you cannot even give him props for it because it could be any one of his collaborators. Even in this case, the neat sound was borrowed from Elliot Goldenthal's infinitely superior HEAT (1995).
Now I will submit that tight deadlines and long scores have warranted collaborations throughout the history of Hollywood. Herrmann and Newman teamed up on The Egyptian, Goldsmith relied on Arthur Morton or Alexander Courage to flesh out his ideas in their orchestrations. Very few composers have actually "gone it alone" because it IS almost impossible to compose, orchestrate, conduct, record, a symphony's worth of music in 3 weeks. James Newton Howard has his own band of merry men he used for the breakneck scoring of King Kong (2005). Even Howard Shore, who does orchestrate his own scores, has assistants. In this business, you need supports.
The question is, how entrenched are those supports in the creative process. Where Goldsmith or Shore or whomever still retained complete control of the notes they were putting to paper, Zimmer gets his mates to actually compose parts of the score. This render any singular style impotent and the musical continuity or "voice" of the film is derailed because you have different personalities approaching each scene independently. This makes it difficult to have some kind of inherent narrative flow and development of thematic ideas through the score which also explains why almost every moment from a MV score sounds like the big climax from the film (at least the blockbuster scores). It's because the one guy working on that single scene is treating it that way.