Consejo sobre columnas frontales

Despues de leer este hilo, creo que se podría resumir que una cosa es la capacidad física del altavoz (hasta dónde puede bajar etc), y otra es la configuración que le de cada fabricante, yo entiendo que por ejemplo un fabricante como Magnat ha decidido meter una configuración que le de la máxima chicha a los graves (¿quizás pensando en usuarios sin Subwoofer?) mientras que otros prefieren darle otra configuración de más medios por ejemplo pensando que la parte baja/graves se va a encargar un subwoofer. Las diferencias vienen dadas más bien por la configuración que no por la capacidad de este o el otro altavoz. Seguramente también podemos decir que un subwoofer de 12" tiene más capacidad de bajar más que uno de 6", otra cosa es que por configuración uno lo haga más que otro, pero entiendo que si hablamos de capacidad sí que físicamente uno es capaz de bajar más que el otro. (que me corrijan por favor si me equivoco que puede ser perfectamente).

Haciendo un símil, yo puedo tener un coche con motor 2.5 de 180cv y un 1.8 de 200cv, en este caso el de menor motor me da más caballos, verdad q puede darse ese hecho? Otra cosa es que el motor 2.5 pudiera haberse configurado para dar 200cv o 300cv o los que tuviera capacidad, quizás el fabricante del 2.5 ha pensado en "sólo" 180 cv porque en su configuración prima el consumo, rumorosidad / confort, longevidad, no sé, por lo que sea en definitiva tiene otra configuración, pero podría haber hecho cualquier otra.

Más o menos es eso. Es cuestión de diseño según criterio del ingeniero.

Magnat en la serie Supreme se ha decantado por cajas que suelen bajar bastante para el tamaño de driver empleado.


Lo mismo ocurre con los drivers: no todos los drivers de mismo tamaño bajan igual; como hemos podido observar hay ciertos drivers de 12" cuya Fs es más alta que algunos drivers de 5". Luego que un 12" generalmente baje más que la mayoría de 5" no implica que todos los 12" bajen más que todos los drivers de 5".. al igual que aunque la mayoría de cajas que montan dos 8" o dos 10" no bajan a 20hz no implica que cajas como las Magnat Supreme 2000 con dos 8" no pueda bajar a 20hz (porque sí que lo hacen). :)


Un saludete
 
¿que tal las nuevas polk audio tsx 330? (sustituyen a las tsi)
 
¿hay graficas de las supreme 1000? ¿Como son estas con respecto a las 2000?
 
Al menos ya le han puesto conos algo mayores que el modelo al que sen teoría sustitiuyen, pasando de 5" 1/4" a 6 1/2":

TSx330T - Floorstanding | Polk Audio®
TSi300 - Floorstanding | Polk Audio®

Espero que hayan mejorado el diseño acústico de sus antecesoras (sobretodo en la coherencia en la zona de cruce y extensión real en graves).



un saludete

Parece que también han mejorado bastante la acústica:

Polk Audio TSx Series Home Theater Speakers - eCoustics.com

Polk Audio has updated its high-performance, high-value TSi speaker lineup, first released in early 2008, with the completely redesigned TSx Series home theater speakers, which offer a curvilinear cabinet design, improved bass, greater dynamic range improved imaging, better detail, and superior sensitivity.
The revamped TSx speaker line, as it’s now known, will bring with it a whole host of audio improvements, including new voicing, with an emphasis on the accurate reproduction of high frequencies that is so critical to the uncompressed high-resolution of today’s Blu-ray discs, as well as improved bass thanks to a shift from 5.25” drivers to new 6.5” specially formulated fibrous bilaminate substrate cones made of pulp infused special polymer compounds that improve stiffening without adding mass.
Polk Audio TSx 440t - feetAt the head of the line is the new TSx 550T, a flagship tower speaker featuring a 1″ Dynamic Balance Tweeter, two 5.25” midrange/mid bass drivers, in a new three-way design that includes two 8-inch low frequency drivers with a 3″ front firing flared port.
As with the TSi series, there will also be two other tower speakers in the lineup. The TSx 440T (pictured above) features the same 1″ Dynamic Balance Tweeter as the 550T, along with three 6.5″ midrange drivers and a 3″ front firing flared port. The TSx 330T, which relies on a 1” tweeter and 3″ front firing flared port, with two 6.5″ midrange drivers.
Other new models include two new bookshelf speakers — the TSx 220B featuring a 1” tweeter and 6.5” driver and TSx 110B featuring a 1” tweeter and 5.25” driver, respectively—as well as two center channel speakers, both of which feature Dynamic Balance Tweeters. The TSx 150C features the line’s 1″ Dynamic Balance Tweeter with a pair of 5.25″ midrange drivers and a 2″ inch rear firing flared port; the TSx 250C boasts a larger cabinet to make room for its pair of 6.5″ midrange drivers, and also features a 2″ inch rear firing flared port.
All of the TSx series speakers come with high-quality five-way binding post speaker connections—single connections for the center channels and bookshelves; dual bi-wirable speaker connections for the towers—and a choice of Black Oak or Cherry finishes.
“When it came time to start transitioning from TSi to the TSx line, we worked hard to make sure we didn’t make changes for changes’ sake,” says Mark Suskind, Vice President of Product Line Management at Polk Audio. “We knew what made the original line such a hit with our customers, and we never lost sight of that as we upgraded the bass, improved the high-frequency response, and refined the aesthetics of our new TSx speakers. A lot has changed, but one thing remains the same: With our love of music, Polk has always been committed to making things sound better with every product we make. These new TSx speakers continue to fulfill this promise and deliver outstanding performance at truly reasonable prices.”
 
Parece que también han mejorado bastante la acústica:

Polk Audio TSx Series Home Theater Speakers - eCoustics.com

Polk Audio has updated its high-performance, high-value TSi speaker lineup, first released in early 2008, with the completely redesigned TSx Series home theater speakers, which offer a curvilinear cabinet design, improved bass, greater dynamic range improved imaging, better detail, and superior sensitivity.
The revamped TSx speaker line, as it’s now known, will bring with it a whole host of audio improvements, including new voicing, with an emphasis on the accurate reproduction of high frequencies that is so critical to the uncompressed high-resolution of today’s Blu-ray discs, as well as improved bass thanks to a shift from 5.25” drivers to new 6.5” specially formulated fibrous bilaminate substrate cones made of pulp infused special polymer compounds that improve stiffening without adding mass.
Polk Audio TSx 440t - feetAt the head of the line is the new TSx 550T, a flagship tower speaker featuring a 1″ Dynamic Balance Tweeter, two 5.25” midrange/mid bass drivers, in a new three-way design that includes two 8-inch low frequency drivers with a 3″ front firing flared port.
As with the TSi series, there will also be two other tower speakers in the lineup. The TSx 440T (pictured above) features the same 1″ Dynamic Balance Tweeter as the 550T, along with three 6.5″ midrange drivers and a 3″ front firing flared port. The TSx 330T, which relies on a 1” tweeter and 3″ front firing flared port, with two 6.5″ midrange drivers.
Other new models include two new bookshelf speakers — the TSx 220B featuring a 1” tweeter and 6.5” driver and TSx 110B featuring a 1” tweeter and 5.25” driver, respectively—as well as two center channel speakers, both of which feature Dynamic Balance Tweeters. The TSx 150C features the line’s 1″ Dynamic Balance Tweeter with a pair of 5.25″ midrange drivers and a 2″ inch rear firing flared port; the TSx 250C boasts a larger cabinet to make room for its pair of 6.5″ midrange drivers, and also features a 2″ inch rear firing flared port.
All of the TSx series speakers come with high-quality five-way binding post speaker connections—single connections for the center channels and bookshelves; dual bi-wirable speaker connections for the towers—and a choice of Black Oak or Cherry finishes.
“When it came time to start transitioning from TSi to the TSx line, we worked hard to make sure we didn’t make changes for changes’ sake,” says Mark Suskind, Vice President of Product Line Management at Polk Audio. “We knew what made the original line such a hit with our customers, and we never lost sight of that as we upgraded the bass, improved the high-frequency response, and refined the aesthetics of our new TSx speakers. A lot has changed, but one thing remains the same: With our love of music, Polk has always been committed to making things sound better with every product we make. These new TSx speakers continue to fulfill this promise and deliver outstanding performance at truly reasonable prices.”

Típico marketing de toda empresa cuando saca un modelo nuevo. Cuando lo analicen veremos lo que hay. :)

Un saludete
 
Atrás
Arriba