Tema
FSM: Integristas porque los representantes de las principales editoras /distribuidoras del mundillo que por allí pululan, así cómo ciertos productores reaccionan cómo niñitos malcriados, faltando al respeto e incluso ridiculizando a aquellos aficionados que se atreven a hacer públicas sus meteduras de pata, cuando suceden, y nadie hace absolutamente nada.
Sirva cómo ejemplo el desastroso a todos los niveles lanzamiento por parte de La-la-Land Records (y ya llevan unas cuantas), de la edición expandida del
Superman Returns, de
John Ottman, donde la masterización es absolutamente horrorosa, y el término
Loudness War, se convierte en un eufemismo. Una autentica vergüenza que algo así esté realizado por profesionales, y aún más que pretendan cobrar por ello.
Por supuesto, esto es algo empíricamente demostrable, y entre todos los comentarios de algarabía por el lanzamiento, un usuario lo hizo notar:
"I´ve finally had an opportunity to listen to the 'Superman Returns' set I ordered a month ago.
It´s a nice set: cover design looks beautiful, the liner notes are top-notch.
The sound however is a different matter.
For heaven's sake, why is it so loud? Why was every loud piece effectively destroyed? I´m not kidding: transients are crushed, clipping artifacts are very audible.
You guys at LLL, this is an orchestra, not some recent release by Justin Bieber, it can´t be treated like the next best mainstream thing. This score isn´t supposed to enter the charts, you know.
It´s not the first time either. I bought your 'Matrix Reloaded' set too where - instead of treating the flaws - you made it as loud as possible (again with destroyed transients, even though it wasn´t as audible as on the 'Superman' set).
Let this be a warning to LLL: I will stop buying your releases should you continue to treat their sound without respect".
Doug Schwartz did the mastering for 'Superman Returns', Mike Mattessino for 'Matrix Reloaded'. And yes, I´ll stop buying those releases, releases where material is intentionally destroyed to appeal either to mainstream-buying hordes of people (with stuff limited to 3000 pieces?) or to young crowds.
It may not be audible to everyone but to me it´s extremely disturbing, I notice it every time the orchestra gets louder. Well, it´s audible and - for me - it destroys the mood the music tries to set.
Brickwall limiting producing audible artifacts is - for orchestral scores - one thing only: unnecessary.
You´ve mentioned several other releases by LLL... I´ve kept quiet regarding them. And I will continue to do so because I still remember the reaction when I complained about 'Hook'. It´s pointless and hopeless anyway.
Doy fé de lo de
Hook, por cierto.
Y esta fue la respuesta, racional, humilde, respetuosa y meditada de un miembro de
La-la-Land que postea en el foro.
lol
Un forero sale en su defensa:
Good luck pointing out any mastering problems Marlene.
"The last time I bothered with that everyone called me deaf and suggested that I must have defective hardware. I just praise God that there aren't usually any audible pops and crackles from clipping like you hear in some Japanese releases. I can't even listen to half of the major releases by Yoshihisa Hirano (Death Note for one) because the big choral works have insane amounts of clipping. Certain releases I just have to deal with it because that is the only thing available.
It is impossible to avoid poorly mastered orchestral work. I would never buy anything if I expected everything to sound like a Naxos release. Thankfully Intrada and Kritzerland rarely use the crazy amounts of gain and I haven't encountered anything so bad I couldn't listen to it from anything I got from La La Land".
Más adelante, el forero inicial se extiende en sus comentarios :
I didn´t want to answer in this thread anymore after LLL posted the picture from 'Chinatown' which I took as not being taken serious.
Well, here I go... there actually are many pieces where peaks are crushed. Now this wouldn´t bother me at all if it would have been done right. The original release had brickwall limiting too; it wasn´t THAT audible though. And here it´s very, very audible.
Then dynamics are inconsistent over the whole set: some pieces are partially so soft that you can´t hear anything ('04. Homecoming - Tell Me Everything - Stars in the Sky'). Other pieces - which should be soft as well judging from orchestration and a now audible noisefloor - are almost as loud as the major action pieces ('12. Superman Scoop - Eavesdropping' springs to mind... or track 4 again where the last 30 seconds are much louder than the rest). All of this goes on and on and on...
Then four tracks are equalized differently than the rest: Tracks 23, 30, 31, 32 (more treble, less mids, more upper bass, less deep bass) are sounding brittle and tinny.
Inconsistent gain levels, badly done brickwall limiting, inconsistent EQ: it´s the worst re-master I´ve heard since 'Hook.
Y La-La-land se corona:
he problem here is we can't take a nameless customer such as yourself seriously. You hide behind a computer screen and spout hateful bs on labels (consistently). You are pissing and moaning about Doug Schwartz's mastering job on Superman Returns and referring to us as kids? Doug is a highly respected engineer who has more experience in this field than anyone we have ever worked with. Who do you think mastered most of the FSM releases?
Do yourself a favor and stop buying our product if it makes you that unhappy. You'll live longer
En fin. Y los moderadores no hacen nada, porque claro, es una inmensa suerte tener a profesionales del sector entre nosotros, aunque se comporten todos a bailarle el agua, que bastante curro tiene el haberlo lanzado, encima no vengas a quejarte.
Ellos sabrán. Pero esa actitud de que algo por ser oficial es cojonudo y sólo merece loas y agradecimiento, es la más absurda que he visto en mucho tiempo.