SUPERMAN: THE CHRISTOPHER REEVE COLLECTION
Richard Donner's cut of Superman II is a very different beast.
HERE'S a simple maths question: What's 80 per cent of 70 per cent? If you answered, "56 per cent", give yourself a pat on the back. If you answered, "The total surviving footage that Richard Donner shot for Superman II, before he was fired and replaced by Richard Lester," then spark up a big fat cigar.
Directors have been fired from big movie before, but the story of what happened to Donner on Superman II is a doozy. The idea had always been for Donner to shoot both Superman movies at the same time but, with an unforgiving post-production schedule demanding that Superman be released in 1978, the director suspended shooting on the sequel 70 per cent of the way through, fully intending to resume once Superman was released.
He never got the chance. Throughout the shoot, Donner had had a fractious relationship with producers Alexander and Ilya Salkind and Pierre Spengler, and after Superman became a hit they decided to replace Donner (although Spengler claim on his DVD commentary that Donner turned down the chance to finish the movie). Their gamble was that the title character, not the director, was the lure for audiences.
In a way, they were right: in came Lester, the British director of A Hard Day's Night, and his 1980 movie - which contains about 20 per cent of the finished Donner footage - grossed over $100 millions in the States alone. The movie also fared well with critics and fans, despite a schizophrenia that stems from the clash of Lester's wackier footage with the reverential tone of Donner's stuff.
But the desire to see Donner's version, widely seen as the 'true' Superman II, remained, and eventually an internet campaign was mounted to convince Warner Bros to allow Donner to complete his cut. The campign paid off, and now Richard Donner's cut of Superman II dominates a superb nine-disc box set, which collects all four (or five) Christoper Reeve Superman films.
Of course, this still isn't really the Donner cut. Our simple equation put paid to that - if only 56 per cent of Donner's film is still available, the it fell to Donner and his editor, Michael Thau, to plug the gaps in the narrative with Lester footage. Nevertheless, watching the 'new' movie is a fascinating experience, and as close as we're ever going to get to the movie that Donner intended to make.
Plotwise, it's ostensibly the same - Lois Lane discovers Clark Kent is Superman; he gives up his power to be with her...at the same time as three Kryptonian villains, led by Terrance Stamp's General Zod, come to Earth. Tonally, though, this is a darker film, with much of the slapstick comedy removed, while Donner focuses on Superman's responsibilities to mankind in favour of the love of his life, and then to beg for the return of his powers, knowing all the while that it mean losing a chance at true happiness.
The presence of Marlon Brando, as a ghostly version of Jor-El, Superman's father, lends these scenes further weight. Brando had already filmed all his scenes for both Superman films before Donner was fired, but the Salkinds would have had to pay him an extra fee if he appeared in Superman II - they refused to do so and drafted in Susannah York, as Kal-El's mum, to carry out the same service but more cheaply. (Along similar lines, Gene Hackman refused to shoot any footage for Lester, hence Lex Luthor's diminished presence in both cuts.)
Elsewhere, the goofy opening sequence in Paris (complete with comedy French terrorists) had gone, while Stamp's vaudevillian performance, which has over the years gathered quite a cult following, has been calmed down significantly, with Donner choosing quieter line readings that remoulded Zod into a genuinely sinister nemesis for the Man of Steel.
However, given that this is housed in the Christoper Reeves box set, it would be remiss not to wax lyrical about the actor, who will, no matter how good Brandon Routh becomes, always be the Man of Steel. [spolier] In Lester's Superman II, Lois discovers that Clark is Superman when he slips, jabs his hand into a fire and is miraculously unharmed. Donner, though, always intented to feature a scene in which the wily Lois tricked Clark into revealing himself by threatening him with a gun...loaded with blanks. Because of that whole pesky P45 business, he never filmed it. So in its stead are the original screen tests for Reeves and Margot Kidder, edited together into a vaguely coherent whole. It's patchy (Reeve's hairstyle changes fom shot to shot), badly lit and stagy, but watching Reeve's peformance is electrifying: as the 'gunshot' rings out, the change in his body language, from hunched-over, insecured, dweebish Clark to the upright, stoic and slightly angry Kal-El is simply astonishing. [fin spoiler]
So, when the dust has settled, which is the last Superman standing? Well, despite all the care and attention lavished on Donner's version, it just doesn't hang together as well as Lester's zippier, funnier cut. But as a peek into a time capsule that might otherwise have stayed shut forever, it's endlessly fascinating.
--CHRIS HEWITT